伪装下的谎言:关于作弊的实验研究

LIES IN DISGUISE-AN EXPERIMENTAL STUDY ON CHEATING

Journal of the European Economic Association · 2013
被引 1245 · 同刊同年前 2%
人大 AABS 4

中文导读

设计了一个掷骰子实验,参与者私下掷骰并报告结果,通过比较报告与真实分布来测量诚实与说谎行为,发现约20%的人完全说谎,39%完全诚实,其余部分说谎。

Abstract

We present a novel experimental design to measure honesty and lying. Participants receive a die which they roll privately. Since their payoff depends on the reported roll of the die, the subjects have an incentive to be dishonest and report higher numbers to get a higher payoff. This design has three advantages. First, cheating cannot be detected on the individual level, which reduces potential demand effects. Second, the method is very easy to implement. Third, the underlying true distribution of the outcome under full honesty is known, and hence it is possible to test different theoretical predictions. We find that about 20% of inexperienced subjects lie to the fullest extent possible while 39% of subjects are fully honest. In addition, a high share of subjects consists of partial liars; these subjects lie, but do not report the payoff-maximizing draw. We discuss different motives that explain the observed behavioral pattern.

欺骗实验诚实行为部分说谎骰子实验