在语境中分析文本:组织研究中批判性话语分析的当前实践与新协议

Analysing Texts in Context: Current Practices and New Protocols for Critical Discourse Analysis in Organization Studies

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES · 2009
被引 152
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

指出组织研究中的批判性话语分析(CDA)对“语境”的定义和应用存在分歧,提出了九项方法论协议以提升研究的一致性和严谨性,有助于学者评估CDA研究的质量。

Abstract

abstract Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) in organization studies would be strengthened by an increased focus on a central CDA tenet that texts should be analysed in context. Context has, for the most part, been afforded a taken‐for‐granted status that is misplaced because of the diverse ways in which it may be defined and applied. These generally unacknowledged differences relate to whether context is treated as space, time, practice, change, or frame. The result is a confusing array of studies claiming some degree of CDA status without core agreement – or acknowledgement of disagreements – about what is meant by context or how it should be linked to texts. To remedy this situation we identify in this Point article nine methodological protocols related to conceptual definitions, data selection, and data analysis which we argue benefit the consistency and rigour with which CDA in organization studies is applied. Use of these protocols may also serve as criteria against which the rigour of CDA research papers may be assessed.

组织研究批判性话语分析方法论语境分析