先占规则与法律设计

The Rule of First Possession and the Design of the Law

Journal of Law & Economics · 1995
被引 189
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

建立模型分析先占如何避免租值耗散,并解释不同法律领域中先占规则的差异,关键在于区分先占是针对资源存量还是流量。

Abstract

Economists have shown that first possession might cause rent dissipation from racing or overexploitation. In this study, I develop models that show how dissipation can be avoided and use the derived implications to explain the observed pattern of first possession rules in a variety of legal fields. The analysis hinges on the recognition that possession may extend to either the entire stock of a resource or simply a onetime flow from that stock. Not only do the paths of rent dissipation depend on this distinction, but so do the predicted responses of the law. When first possession has the potential for a race, the law tends to mitigate dissipation by assigning possession when differences between claimants are greatest. Alternatively, when first possession leads to overexploitation through a rule of capture, the law tends to limit access and restrict the transfer of access rights in order to limit open access dissipation.

先占规则租值耗散捕获规则产权设计