赋予完全产权的土地改革是否具有政治风险?墨西哥认证计划的选举结果

Are land reforms granting complete property rights politically risky? Electoral outcomes of Mexico's certification program

Journal of Development Economics · 2013
被引 102
人大 AABS 3

中文导读

研究墨西哥土地认证计划对投票行为的影响,发现赋予完全产权导致选民转向支持市场导向的右翼政党,但受益者并未回报执政党。

Abstract

What is the impact on voting behavior of strengthening property rights over agricultural land? To answer this question, we use the 14-year nationwide rollout of Mexico's land certification program (Procede) and match affected communities (ejidos) before and after the change in property rights with voting outcomes in corresponding electoral sections across six federal election cycles. We find that, in accordance with the investor class theory, granting complete property rights induced a conservative shift toward the pro-market party equal to 6.8 percent of its average share of votes over the period. This shift was strongest where vested interests created larger expected benefits from market-oriented policies as opposed to public-transfer policies. We also find that beneficiaries failed to reciprocate through votes for the benefactor party. We conclude that, in the Mexican experience, engaging in a land reform that strengthened individual property rights over agricultural land was politically advantageous for the right-wing party.

土地确权投票行为墨西哥Procede计划