信用与分类:十九世纪美国行业边界的影响

Credit and Classification: The Impact of Industry Boundaries in Nineteenth-Century America

ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCE QUARTERLY · 2009
被引 235
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

研究了美国早期工业分类体系(邓氏公司信用评级)中多重类别成员身份(混合性)的处理方式,发现分类系统未固化时混合性不成问题,但制度化后跨行业行为会受惩罚。

Abstract

In this article, we examine how issues of multi-category membership (hybridity) were handled during the evolution of one of the first general systems of industrial classification in the United States, the credit rating schema of R. G. Dun and Company. Drawing on a repeated cross-sectional study of credit evaluations during the postbellum period (1870–1900), our empirical analyses suggest that organizational membership in multiple categories need not be problematic when classification systems themselves are emergent or in flux and when organizations avoid rare combinations or identities involving ambiguous components. As Dun's schema became institutionalized, boundaries between industries were more clearly defined and boundary violations became subject to increased attention and penalty by credit reporters. Our perspective highlights the utility of an evolutionary perspective and tests its implications for the salience of distinct mechanisms of hybridity.

组织理论分类系统经济史信用评级