认知偏好反转还是市场价格反转?

Cognitive Preference Reversal or Market Price Reversal?

Kyklos · 2005
被引 2
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

通过实验(N=186)发现偏好反转现象实际上是市场中的价格反转,在控制市场操纵后偏好传递性得以恢复,并改进了测量方法。

Abstract

Summary Preference Reversal Phenomenon (PRP) has been most often scrutinized as a puzzle of ‘preferences’, while the discovery of the ‘endowment effect’ explicitly questions the parity between preference and price. The author's experiment (N = 186) connects these two extraordinary findings and illustrates that PRP is only a reversal of price in a ‘market.’ PRP merely proves that subjects demand to be compensated based on loss under market access deprivation when a ‘maximum buying’/‘minimum selling’ price is elicited, and preference transitivity is restored once the misleading market manipulation is experimentally controlled. By defending preference transitivity, the author asserts that normal access to the bargaining process is indispensable for a competitive market where preference price parity is required. To make valid measurements of preference and price, the sealed envelope method is substituted for the judged‐indifferent‐point (JIP) method, and the binding statement method is substituted for the Becker‐DeGroot‐Marschack method. McNemar test scores are calculated to compare the effects of different methods.

偏好反转禀赋效应市场准入偏好传递性