直接民主的效率

The Efficiency of Direct Democracy

Journal of Political Economy · 1980
被引 39
人大 A+FT50ABS 4*

中文导读

研究直接民主的帕累托效率,通过模型测量偏好强度,分析100多个瑞士公投发现多数情况下投票结果有效,少数无效案例中少数派可补偿多数派。

Abstract

The paper investigates the Pareto efficiency of direct democracy and searches for the frequency with which the losing minority in referendum voting could compensate the majority and still be better off. A model is defined that permits the measuring of the intensity of preferences in a population, based on voting and abstention behavior. Using the model, an analysis of over 100 Swiss referenda reveals only a few instances in which the outcome of direct voting is inefficient. It seems that the political system evolves methods of trade-off that permit efficient outcomes in most cases. Criticism of direct democracy should therefore not rely on the primarily hypothetical objection of inefficiency.

直接民主帕累托效率公民投票瑞士公投