实时审计复核导致证据的决策前扭曲

Predecisional Distortion of Evidence as a Consequence of Real-Time Audit Review

Accounting Review · 2002
被引 248
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

实验发现,审计师在评估证据前知晓主管观点,会扭曲对证据的评价并做出更符合主管观点的判断,而审计师未预料到这种早期知晓会加剧下属的认同倾向。

Abstract

With the current shift toward real-time audit review, subordinates become aware of supervisors' views earlier in the audit process. I use an experiment to examine whether earlier knowledge of supervisors' views increases subordinates' tendencies to agree with those views because subordinates predecisionally distort evidence. In a going-concern task, I find that auditors who learn the partner's view before evaluating evidence (1) evaluate individual evidence items as more consistent with the partner's view, and (2) make going-concern judgments that are more consistent with the partner's view, than do auditors who learn the same partner's view after evaluating evidence. In a second experiment, I examine whether auditors anticipate the distortion's effect on subordinates' judgments. I find that auditors expect subordinates to make judgments that agree with supervisors' views, but auditors do not expect subordinates to agree even more with those views when subordinates learn those views earlier in the audit process.

审计实时复核决策前证据扭曲审计判断上级意见影响