回复:考虑主要发现——对威廉·T·罗斯的回复

Reply—Consider the Principal Finding: A Reply to William T. Ross

Management Science · 1988
被引 1
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

回应威廉·T·罗斯的评论,指出其关注点偏离了研究的主要发现:实验团队并未完全被人类团队压倒,并强调复制研究比事后统计分析更能阐明实质问题。

Abstract

By focussing on issues concerning precise relative performance of the human and experimental teams, Ross obscures the major, and a priori surprising result of our study. This is that the experimental teams were not all dominated by the human teams. Replication is the appropriate way to illuminate the substantive issues raised by our study rather than arguments based on ex-post and possibly questionable statistical analyses.

实验团队人类团队绩效比较复制研究