New market socialism: a case for rejuvenation or inspired alchemy?
考察了Bardhan和Roemer提出的两种新市场社会主义模型的优缺点,通过历史视角和内部一致性检验,评估其是否真正推动了相关辩论。
The aim of this paper is to examine the relative merits and drawbacks of two recent models of market socialism proposed by Bardhan and Roemer. This is done, first, by putting these models into the perspective of the history of economic thought. Thus, after presenting the basic elements of the early Lange model as well as the Austrian and 'new information economics' critiques, the necessary comparisons and contrasts are made to see what new light these new models bring into this debate. In addition, the internal consistency and coherence of these models is checked in terms of their own proclaimed goals. Last, a more radical methodological critique is provided. Copyright 2003, Oxford University Press.