资本主义经济权力的本体论:主流经济学与马克思

The ontology of economic power in capitalism: mainstream economics and Marx

Cambridge Journal of Economics · 2006
被引 33
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

批判主流经济学将权力与完全竞争对立的观点,基于马克思和批判实在论,论证资本主义本身就是一个权力体系,权力与竞争的本体论二分站不住脚。

Abstract

Mainstream economics conceives power to be incompatible with perfect competition. This conception, I argue, derives from its deductivist method and the ‘empirical realist’ ontology that it presupposes. Following Marx, I show that capitalism constantly reproduces asymmetrical constraints on classes of individuals, independent of the market form. My ontological argument is rooted in the philosophy of ‘critical realism’. My conclusion is that the dichotomy ‘power–competition’ is ontologically untenable. If capitalist relations necessarily involve power, it is not simply because neoclassical competition does not exist in reality, as radical mainstream economists suggest, but rather because capitalism altogether is a ‘system of power’.

经济权力资本主义本体论马克思主义经济学批判实在论