管理者应该使用团队竞赛吗?

Should Managers Use Team-Based Contests?

Management Science · 2013
被引 71
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

研究团队竞赛与个人竞赛对员工努力的影响,发现当参赛者害怕让团队失望时,团队竞赛能激发更高努力,尤其当参赛者有机会与队友社交时效果更明显。

Abstract

When designing contests to motivate employees, should managers organize employees to compete in teams or as individuals? We develop a behavioral economics model that shows that if contestants are averse to being responsible for the team's loss, a team-based (TB) contest can yield higher effort than an individual-based (IB) contest. This prediction is contrary to those of standard economics models, which favor IB contests over TB contests. We test the competing predictions using laboratory economics experiments. The results show that when contestants do not know each other, average effort levels in the TB and IB contests are not different. When contestants are allowed to socialize with potential teammates before making effort decisions, TB contests yield higher effort relative to IB contests. We also show that the relative efficacy of TB contests is driven by contestants' aversion to letting their team down. Data, as supplemental material, are available at http://dx.doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.2013.1743 . This paper was accepted by Peter Wakker, decision analysis.

团队竞赛个人竞赛努力水平责任规避