迭代三角测量:利用现有案例研究的理论发展过程

Iterative triangulation: a theory development process using existing case studies

JOURNAL OF OPERATIONS MANAGEMENT · 1998
被引 263
人大 AFT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

提出一种名为迭代三角测量的理论发展方法,通过系统迭代文献回顾、案例证据和直觉,利用现有案例研究提高理论创造力、实用性和有效性,并以先进制造技术设计研究为例说明。

Abstract

Abstract To cope with the growing frequency and magnitude of changes in technology and managerial methods, Operations Management (OM) researchers have been calling for greater employment of field‐based research methods. A notable example is grounded theory development using original case studies. Based on in‐depth examinations of ‘real‐world’ operations conditions, case studies potentially improve the relevance and workability of resulting OM theory. However, developing original case studies requires considerable time and expense, straining research resources and often limiting the number of operations settings that can be studied and compared during induction. Existing case studies offer a potentially effective and efficient means for comparing complex and disparate operations settings. This paper proposes a novel theory development process, termed iterative triangulation , for tapping this potential. Iterative triangulation employs systematic iterations between literature review, case evidence, and intuition. The process enhances theory creativity, utility, and validity by deliberately increasing the diversity and quantity of literature reviewed, of cases found, of conjectures examined, and of conjecture selection criteria. Comparing and contrasting emerging constructs and theory across case settings refines conceptual definitions and strengthens internal validity, enhancing testability of resulting theory. A study of advanced manufacturing technology design illustrates the method.

运营管理案例研究理论构建定性研究研究方法