个体化研究解释的有效性

The Validity of Idiographic Research Explanations

Academy of Management Review · 1989
被引 670
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

探讨个体化研究产生的组织解释是否具有外部有效性,主张基于实在论认识论的解释性个体化研究能够提出关于世界的一般性主张,因为因果倾向在特定条件下运作,即使未出现规律性也能产生一般性知识。

Abstract

This paper attempts to address the question of whether organizational explanations produced through idiographic studies can be regarded as externally valid. It is argued that explanatory idiographic studies that are informed by a realist epistemology are, indeed, in a position to make general claims about the world. For realists, generality is distinguished from recurrent regularities; instead, it is ascribed to the operation of causal tendencies (or powers). The latter act in their normal way even when expected regularities do not occur. This is possible because the realization of causal tendencies is contingent upon specific circumstances, which may or may not favor the generation of certain patterns of events. Idiographic research conceptualizes the causal capability of structures, while at the same time it sheds light on the contingent manner through which a set of postulated causal powers interact and gives rise to the flux of the phenomena under study.

个案研究外部效度现实主义因果倾向