俄国农民农业真的那么贫困吗?来自十九世纪末“贫困中心”案例研究的新证据

Was Russian Peasant Agriculture Really That Impoverished? New Evidence from a Case Study from the “Impoverished Center” at the End of the Nineteenth Century

Journal of Economic History · 1983
被引 49 · 同刊同年前 7%
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

质疑俄国史学界关于农民经济濒临崩溃的主流观点,通过修正牲畜统计、土地租赁和休耕减少等指标的错误,重新评估沃罗涅日地区农民农场的贫富状况,为重新审视1917年革命前夕的“农业危机”提供新证据。

Abstract

The mainstream of Russian historiographical studies holds that at the turn of the century peasant economic conditions were in a state of near collapse. In one of the poorest parts of the empire three measures of that economic impoverishment were seriously in error: draft animals were incompletely inventoried, and the meanings of both land leasing and fallow reductions were misinterpreted. These methodological errors have systematically distorted prevailing discussions about the wealth and poverty of peasant farms in Voronezh. Accumulating evidence is beginning to suggest reopening the question of the severity of the Russian “agrarian crisis” on the eve of the Revolution of 1917.

俄国农民经济农业危机沃罗涅日省世纪末