经济学悖论札记

A Note on Paradoxes in Economics

Kyklos · 2004
被引 0
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

指出曼德维尔悖论(看不见的手)与囚徒困境(市场失灵)不能同时成立,因为两者主张相反,并提出了解决这一“悖论之悖论”的初步思路,呼吁经济学家更多研究直觉或民间经济学。

Abstract

Summary A paradox is a proposition in (alleged) contrast with common sense. All science is replete with paradoxes. Economics is not an exception. This paper is focused on two widely discussed paradoxes: the Mandeville paradox (and the associated idea of an ‘invisible hand’) and the Prisoners' Dilemma (with the allied literature on market failures). The main tenet of this paper is that they cannot be simultaneously paradoxical, because they state one the opposite of the other. If common sense contrasts with Mandeville, then it must agree with the Prisoners' Dilemma and vice versa . This is what I term the ‘paradox of paradoxes’ in economics, which is a simple consequence of the rarely noticed principle that two opposing propositions cannot be paradoxical at the same time. A tentative way out from this impasse is presented. I claim that economists would gain a better understanding of their profession if they devoted more time to the study of the intuitive or folk economics.

曼德维尔悖论囚徒困境悖论悖论民间经济学