Russian Tariffs and Foreign Industries before 1914: The German Entrepreneur's Perspective
利用德国工业档案证据，研究关税对企业和企业家的实际影响，发现其他贸易障碍（如信贷、服务、运费等）远超关税的抑制作用，企业家策略也削弱了关税的经济角色。
The present study dealing with Russia and Germany undertakes to investigate the practical effect of tariffs on business and entrepreneur rather than the oft-discussed role of tariffs in international politics. Evidence from German industrial archives demonstrates that businesses were less concerned with tariff issues than one might expect from firms depending on exports. It shows that impediments other than customs duties (expenditures for credit, service, freight, investment, marketing; and competition, restrictions imposed on government orders, subventions, production costs abroad, technological changes) by far overshadowed inhibiting effects of tariffs. Circumspect responses of the entrepreneur helped to minimize the economic role tariffs played.