短信禁令与道路致命事故:它们有效吗?还是司机只是对禁令公告做出反应?

Texting Bans and Fatal Accidents on Roadways: Do They Work? Or Do Drivers Just React to Announcements of Bans?

American Economic Journal: Applied Economics · 2013
被引 107
人大 A-ABS 4

中文导读

研究美国各州短信禁令对交通事故的影响,发现严格执法能短期减少单车单人事故,但效果很快消失,司机似乎只是对禁令公告做出反应。

Abstract

Since 2007, many states passed laws prohibiting text messaging while driving. Using vehicular fatality data from across the United States and standard difference-in-differences techniques, bans appear moderately successful at reducing single-vehicle, single-occupant accidents if bans are universally applied and enforced as a primary offense. Bans enforced as secondary offenses, however, have at best no effect on accidents. Any reduction in accidents following texting bans is short-lived, however, with accidents returning to near former levels within a few months. This is suggestive of drivers reacting to the announcement of the legislation only to return to old habits shortly afterward.

驾驶时发短信禁令交通事故致死禁令效果驾驶员行为反应