韦尔斯利学院反分数膨胀政策的效果

The Effects of an Anti-Grade Inflation Policy at Wellesley College

Journal of Economic Perspectives · 2014
被引 95
人大 A-ABS 4

中文导读

研究韦尔斯利学院将大部分课程平均分上限设为B+的政策,发现该政策压缩了高分段的成绩分布,扩大了种族间的成绩差距,并减少了受限制学科的选课人数和专业选择。

Abstract

Average grades in colleges and universities have risen markedly since the 1960s. Critics express concern that grade inflation erodes incentives for students to learn; gives students, employers, and graduate schools poor information on absolute and relative abilities; and reflects the quid pro quo of grades for better student evaluations of professors. This paper evaluates an anti-grade-inflation policy that capped most course averages at a B+. The cap was biding for high-grading departments (in the humanities and social sciences) and was not binding for low-grading departments (in economics and sciences), facilitating a difference-in-differences analysis. Professors complied with the policy by reducing compression at the top of the grade distribution. It had little effect on receipt of top honors, but affected receipt of magna cum laude. In departments affected by the cap, the policy expanded racial gaps in grades, reduced enrollments and majors, and lowered student ratings of professors.

反成绩膨胀政策成绩分布压缩种族成绩差距学生评教