被规训:英国伞兵团的抱负、纪律与身份工作

`Being Regimented': Aspiration, Discipline and Identity Work in the British Parachute Regiment

ORGANIZATION STUDIES · 2009
被引 385 · 同刊同年前 10%
人大 AABS 4

中文导读

分析英国伞兵团士兵的理想自我观念如何被组织话语规训,提出“抱负者”概念,揭示身份认同在权力框架下的建构与能动性。

Abstract

This paper analyses how the preferred self-conceptions of men in an elite military unit — the British Parachute Regiment — were disciplined by the organizationally based discursive resources on which they drew. The research contribution this paper makes is twofold. First, we argue that preferred self-conceptions (i.e. desired identities) are mechanisms for disciplining employees' identity work, and analyse how paratroopers were subject to, and constituted by, the discursive practices of the Regiment. Paratroopers' preferred conceptions of their selves were disciplined by understandings both of what it meant to be a paratrooper and of the institutional processes by which they were made. In talking about how the Regiment `manufactured' them, paratroopers provided insight on how the Regiment produced and reproduced the idealized identities to which they aspired. Second, to complement other understandings of identities, we suggest that people are often best characterized as `aspirants'. An aspirational identity is a story-type or template in which an individual construes him- or herself as one who is earnestly desirous of being a particular kind of person and self-consciously and consistently in pursuit of this objective. The recognition of subjectively construed identities as narrativized permits an appreciation of individuals as sophisticatedly agentic, while recognizing that their `choices' are made within frameworks of disciplinary power which both enable and restrict their scope for discursive manoeuvre.

组织行为学身份认同军事社会学权力与规训