社会经济地位的某些指标可能不可靠,使用这些数据的指数可能加剧不平等

Some indicators of socio‐economic status may not be reliable and use of indices with these data could worsen equity

Health Economics · 2006
被引 49
人大 A-

中文导读

研究了尼日利亚东南部常用社会经济地位指标和综合指数的可靠性,发现部分指标可靠性低,可能导致资源分配不公,提醒政策制定者谨慎使用。

Abstract

Socio-economic status (SES) indices are increasingly being used to characterise (in)equity, with the assumption that SES indices are reliable. However, the accuracy of such SES indices is questionable if they are unreliable. We examined the inter-rater and test-retest reliability of a range of indicators commonly used to generate SES indices as well as the composite SES indices. Results from research in southeast Nigeria showed considerable variation, with some indicators having only low to moderate reliability (reliability coefficients 0.25-0.77). Inter-rater and test-retest reliability of SES indices was 0.63 in both cases. Many households were misclassified because of the unreliable SES indices. Analyses of the distribution of resources based on such indicators could lead to inaccuracies in benefit incidence estimates and policy decisions based on low to moderately reliable SES indicators could worsen equity in access to and use of resources. Greater rigour is needed in conceptualising as well as undertaking SES measurements.

社会经济地位指标信度公平性资源分配