Pension Fund Activism and Firm Performance
研究1987至1993年间九大养老基金对目标公司的影响,发现多数公司无显著异常回报,仅非代理提案目标公司有正面财富效应,且长期绩效无改善,质疑养老基金积极主义作为公司控制权市场替代的有效性。
This paper studies the efficacy of pension fund activism by examining all firms targeted by nine major funds from 1987 to 1993. I document a movement away from takeover-related proxy proposal targetings in the late 1980s to governance-related proxy proposal and nonproxy proposal targetings in the 1990s. For the vast majority of firms, there are no significant abnormal returns at the time of targeting. The subset of firms subject to nonproxy proposal targeting, however, experiences a significant positive wealth effect. There is no evidence of significant long-term improvement in either stock price or accounting measures of performance in the post-targeting period. Collectively, these results cast doubt on the effectiveness of pension fund activism as a substitute for an active market for corporate control.