玩游戏并努力不迷失自我:一位博士生视角下研究产出的制度压力

Playing the game and trying not to lose myself: a doctoral student’s perspective on the institutional pressures for research output

ORGANIZATION · 2013
被引 119
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

从博士生视角出发,结合福柯的圆形监狱概念,揭示研究产出制度压力如何被话语编码,并指出其导致智力惰性,呼吁通过本体论共情和重新定义成功来改善博士生处境。

Abstract

Several management scholars have recently discussed the consequences that emerge from the institutional pressures for research output. While an important debate for the field, thus far, it has wholly neglected to account for the voices of doctoral students—arguably, the most disempowered constituents within the academy. Working from a doctoral student’s perspective, the aim of this article is to integrate anecdotal evidence with Foucault’s idea of the panopticon gaze so as to illuminate how such institutional pressures become discursively codified. As argued, one especially poignant implication that materializes from the reification of these institutional pressures is intellectual inertia. This article concludes with some consideration of how our discipline can more fruitfully serve doctoral students by holistically embracing the concept of ‘ontological empathy’ and by redefining the meaning of ‘success’. Realization of ontological empathy and the redefinition of success will provide a constructive way to move beyond the orthodoxy of how research output is currently being defined and valued.

管理学高等教育学术制度博士生教育