探究资本主义厌恶

Investigating capitalism aversion

Economic Policy · 2008
被引 32
人大 AABS 3

中文导读

检验了两种解释个人资本主义态度差异的理论:自利动机与对经济体系效率的真实信念。研究发现,自利能解释部分态度差异,但个体学习(缓慢、本土偏好且路径依赖)以及长期文化历史因素(如宗教和法律起源)也起重要作用,且市场态度会影响经济制度。

Abstract

There are two non-mutually exclusive theories of individual variations in pro-capitalism opinions. The first theory views pro-capitalism opinions as self-serving: Individuals are opposed to market forces when they threaten their economic rents. The second theory views differences in such opinions as reflecting genuine disagreement on the efficiency of various economic systems. Using individual data, we investigate the validity of both theories, focusing on attitudes toward private ownership, private profit and competition. We find evidence that the first theory explains some of the variations in attitudes. However, consistent with the second theory, we also find evidence of individual learning about the comparative virtues of economic systems. The learning is slow, home-biased and path-dependent. Long-run cultural and historical determinants of pro-market attitudes, such as religion and legal origins, explain more than 40% of the cross-country variations in capitalism aversion. Last, we provide tentative evidence that at the country level, pro-market opinions affect the nature of economic institutions. Our results suggest that the feasibility of economic reform does not depend solely on its impact on the distribution of rents; ideological a-prioris are likely to be important as well.— Augustin Landier, David Thesmar and Mathias Thoenig

资本主义厌恶私有产权态度经济体制效率认知制度文化决定因素