律师职业的专业性:跨工作情境的比较

The professionalism of practising law: A comparison across work contexts

JOURNAL OF ORGANIZATIONAL BEHAVIOR · 2008
被引 37
人大 AABS 4

中文导读

比较了独立执业律师与律所律师的专业性感知,发现合伙人更接近独立执业者,而合伙人与律师助理之间的差异最大,专业性的差异主要源于客户类型和创收压力。

Abstract

Abstract Traditionally, the literature assumed that solo practitice best exemplifies the ideal professional work arrangement and that when professionals become salaried employees their professionalism is seriously threatened. The primary goal of this paper is to examine lawyers' sense of professionalism across two work contexts: solo practitioner offices and law firm settings. We also examine status distinctions within law firms, between associates and partners, and compare both to independent practitioners. Solo practitioners and law firm partners are similar on most key dimensions of professionalism, whereas the greatest contrasts occur between partners and associates within law firms. Partners and solo practitioners share similar experiences of autonomy and service as owner‐managers, whereas partners and associates share greater collegiality among professionals, perhaps fostered through law firm cultures. All three groups report comparable amounts of variety in their work and are equally committed to the practice of law. The key factors that account for gaps in professionalism reflect the nature of law practices, primarily through time spent with corporate clients and pressure to generate profits. We conclude that different versions of lawyers' professionalism are influenced by the everyday aspects of their work and one version is not necessarily more professional than the other. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

法律职业组织行为职业社会学工作情境