现代主义、后现代主义与组织分析3:雅克·德里达的贡献

Modernism, Post Modernism and Organizational Analysis 3: The Contribution of Jacques Derrida

ORGANIZATION STUDIES · 1989
被引 294 · 同刊同年前 2%
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

探讨德里达的解构、书写和差异概念对组织分析的意义,认为书写逻辑是劳动分工的基础,并解构了组织理论中的官僚制研究模型。

Abstract

This paper, the third in a series on the relevance of the modernist-post modernist debate to organizational analysis (Cooper and Burrell 1988, Burrell 1988), examines the work of Jacques Derrida. Specifically, Derrida's work is viewed as a contribution to the analysis of process (as opposed to structure) in social systems. In this context, three interrelated themes of his work - deconstruction, writing, 'difference' — are described in some detail and their implications explored for social and organizational analysis. Derrida's account of the logic of writing shows it to be fundamental to the division of labour and therefore to significant dimensions (complexity, formalization) of formal organization. Since 'organization theuries' are themselves products of writing and the division of labour, their essential function is to explain and justify the structures they represent, they are therefore more concerned with maintaining their own consistency and the stability of the organized world they describe rather than critical understanding. This point is illustrated by a detailed deconstruction of two major approaches to the study of bureaucracy (the 'formalist' and 'expertise' models) in organization theory. Finally, it is suggested that the affinity between the logic of writing and the division of labour underlies Michel Foucault's concept of knowledge-power and the development of areas of professionalized knowledge such as accountancy.

组织分析后现代主义解构主义社会学管理哲学