不是我的问题,是你的问题:调查项目理解中的错误

It’s Not Me, It’s You

ORGANIZATIONAL RESEARCH METHODS · 2014
被引 67
人大 A-ABS 4

中文导读

通过三项研究发现调查项目存在三种理解错误(指令、句子结构、词汇),这些错误无法用常规统计检测,但会显著影响结果,提醒研究者关注项目理解质量。

Abstract

The ubiquity of surveys in organizational research means that their quality is of paramount importance. Commonly this has been addressed through the use of sophisticated statistical approaches with scant attention paid to item comprehension. Linguistic theory suggests that while everyone may understand an item, they may comprehend it in different ways. We explore this in two studies in which we administered three published scales and asked respondents to indicate what they believed the items meant, and a third study that replicated the results with an additional scale. These demonstrate three forms of miscomprehension: instructional (where instructions are not followed), sentential (where the syntax of a sentence is enriched or depleted as it is interpreted), and lexical (where different meanings of words are deployed). These differences in comprehension are not appreciable using conventional statistical analyses yet can produce significantly different results and cause respondents to tap into different concepts. These results suggest that item interpretation is a significant source of error, which has been hitherto neglected in the organizational literature. We suggest remedies and directions for future research.

组织研究调查方法心理测量语言学认知心理学