私营部门组织中卡夫卡式官僚制的兴起

The ascension of Kafkaesque bureaucracy in private sector organizations

HUMAN RELATIONS · 2013
被引 30
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

研究发现私营部门官僚制充满特殊主义、不确定性和恐惧,更像卡夫卡式而非韦伯式,且这种趋势日益增强,对理解现代私营组织有重要启示。

Abstract

Although Weber’s ideal typical model of bureaucracy was developed primarily in relation to the state, studies of private sector organizations typically adhere to its formal-rational conceptions with little adjustment. This is unfortunate since bureaucracy in private sector economic organizations has many elements that are poorly captured by and potentially significantly at odds with Weber’s thinking. Most notable in this regard is the pervasiveness of particularistic and often informal, emergent arrangements − arrangements well documented for many decades by workplace ethnographers. This has significant implications for the conception of modern private sector organizations and indeed offers a picture that is more Kafkaesque than Weberian. Significant support for this point is provided by an analysis of content coded organizational ethnographies. Weberian dimensions of bureaucracy − most notably coordinated and specialized organization and training − are predominant in public institutions; private sector establishments, in contrast, witness significantly more particularism as well as uncertainty and fear as core organizing principles. Importantly, and as delineated in our over-time comparisons, such Kafkaesque elements of bureaucracy and organization appear to be increasingly prevalent.

官僚制私营部门组织社会学组织民族志