Effects of Classifying Equity or Debt on the Value of the Firm Under Tax Asymmetry
研究在无代理成本和破产成本的世界中，将公司权益或债务按不同优先级分类如何影响总预期税负和公司价值，发现仅有一类权益和至多一类债务时税负最小、价值最大，并解释了公开契约发行公司债券的实践。
This paper examines the effect of classifying a firm's equity or debt into subclasses of unequal seniority on the total expected tax burden of the firm and its security holders in a world with no agency and no bankruptcy costs. It is shown that, when positive income is taxed at a higher rate than that allowed on realized capital losses, expected taxes are minimized and the value of the firm is maximized if the firm has only one class of equity and, at most, one class of debt. This result helps to explain the common practice of issuing corporate bonds under open indentures. In fact, our empirical results indicate that before the advent of a differentiated capital gains tax in 1921, a great majority of publicly traded long-term industrial bonds were issued under closed indentures. By 1951, nearly all such debt was issued under single indentures (i.e., there was only one class of creditor).