环境结构与战略选择理论

ENVIRONMENTAL STRUCTURE AND THEORIES OF STRATEGIC CHOICE

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES · 1988
被引 191
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

批评组织研究中将自愿主义与决定论简单二分,指出这种简化忽视了行动决定论,并提出一种现实主义观点,将环境结构视为战略选择的前提条件。

Abstract

ABSTRACT This article argues that the prevailing dichotomization of organizational studies into voluntarist and deterministic orientations is too simple, and that this simplicity has dangerous consequences for accounts of strategic choice. Determinism has been equated exclusively with the operation of environmental constraint, with the implication that the agency necessary for strategic choice can be secured simply by the removal of this constraint. This focus on external constraint has obscured the continuing influence of ‘action determinist’ positions, in which action is determined by mechanisms internal to the actor him/herself. This article argues that many recent theorists of strategic choice have relied too much on the interpretive voluntarist dissolution of environmental structure and neglected to safeguard themselves from the action determinism latent in the Carnegie tradition. the article proposes an alternative Realist account that, by contrast with interpretive voluntarism, incorporates environmental structure as an essential precondition to actors’ internal and external capacities for strategic choice.

组织研究战略管理社会学经济学哲学