Unpacking the Dialectic: Alternative Views on the Discourse–Materiality Relationship
通过分析五种解释框架(包括福柯式方法和物质性-表演性视角)中话语与物质性关系的假设和特征,主张保持两者之间的辩证张力,并概述各框架如何处理切入点、关系性质及张力管理。
Abstract This paper extends the issues raised in this forum by highlighting assumptions and characteristics of the discourse–materiality relationship that appears in five explanatory frameworks, including the Foucauldian approach and the materiality–performativity perspective presented in the previous two papers. It argues for preserving the dialectical relationship between the two by holding the tensions between them in continual interplay. Using a dialectic lens, it overviews how each of the frameworks treats the point of entry, nature of the relationship, and management of these tensions.