当你的优势威胁到我:上级比下属表现出更少的社会比较偏见

When your strength threatens me: Supervisors show less social comparison bias than subordinates

Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology · 2015
被引 4
ABS 4

中文导读

研究发现,在员工推荐计划中,上级比下属更少因社会比较偏见而拒绝推荐与自己有相同优势的优秀候选人,且自我威胁感是造成这种差异的原因。

Abstract

Employee referral programmes encourage employees to recommend outstanding candidates to their organizations. However, a superior candidate can be a threat to a referee. People tend to not recommend higher performing candidates who have the same strengths as themselves because these candidates can be a threat to their self‐positivity. This is known as social comparison bias (Garcia et al ., 2010, Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process., 113, 97) and has a tendency to hinder the effectiveness of employee referral programmes. We propose that supervisors will show less social comparison bias than their subordinates. Data taken from the results of three experiments and a field study show that supervisors (vs. subordinates) exhibit less social comparison bias (Studies 1a, 1b, and 2), and we learn that self‐threat account for the difference between supervisors and subordinates (Study 2). Moreover, we verify that the difference between supervisors and subordinates in terms of their willingness to provide a recommendation reflects social comparison bias rather than a complementarity concern (Study 3). Practitioner points Positions influence the willingness to provide a recommendation. Supervisors (vs. subordinates) are less threatened by a higher performing other who has the same strength.

心理学社会心理学组织行为学人力资源管理