无处可逃?遗产保护中的协调问题

No Escape? The Coordination Problem in Heritage Preservation

Environment and Planning A Economy and Space · 2015
被引 16
ABS 3

中文导读

研究英国保护区政策是否解决了业主间的囚徒困境,通过分析近百万笔房产交易和111个访谈,发现存在正向遗产外部性,居民认可规划控制并愿意维护社区特色。

Abstract

Conservation Areas (CAs) are among the most restrictive English planning policies. Designation implies a significant limitation of owners' control over the shape and appearance of their properties. The policy, however, can also be argued to solve a sort of ‘prisoner's dilemma’, in which it might be collectively rational to preserve the character of an area, but an individual homeowner may be tempted to inappropriately alter their property, thus free-riding on nearby properties' character. The net benefit of the policy depends largely on the existence of positive ‘heritage effects’ and acknowledgement from homeowners that policy contributes to neighbourhood stability and the preservation of these positive effects. Our results of a mixed-method analysis of close to 1 million property transactions near to about 8000 CAs and 111 interviews with residents in nine representative CAs in Greater London suggest that positive heritage externalities exist and that residents in CAs tend to value their local environments, acknowledge the need for planning control, and execute their right to object to neighbour's planning request.

城市经济学公共经济学遗产保护规划政策