美国地理学家协会年会国际化程度如何?基于社会网络分析的视角

How international is the Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers? A social network analysis perspective

Environment and Planning A Economy and Space · 2015
被引 37
ABS 3

中文导读

通过分析2005年和2013年美国地理学家协会年会论文和专题讨论中的互动地理分布,发现国内联系比国际联系更易实现,且这种内向趋势在加深,对评估学术会议国际化有参考价值。

Abstract

Drawing on an analysis of the geographies of interactions in paper and panel sessions during the Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers in 2005 and 2013, this paper seeks to complement ongoing research on (the lack of) actual international engagements in putatively ‘international’ academic geography. We use a social network analysis framework which, rather than accepting that the mere (rising) presence of international scholars points to internationalization, benchmarks the observed level of international and intra-national interactions in paper and panel sessions against a randomized model. Results show that the Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers is inward looking in the sense that intra-national ties are at least twice more likely to be realized than international ties. Furthermore, in spite of being an increasingly internationally diverse conference in terms of its participants, this tendency towards being inward looking has deepened between 2005 and 2013. Human geography sessions are more inward looking than sessions focusing on modeling, methods and Geographic Information Systems (GIS). The propensity towards intra-national interactions in sessions is found for almost all countries ‘participating’ in the conference. Results are used for a tentative interpretation of the meaning ascribed to the Annual Meeting of the Association of American Geographers. We conclude by discussing the limitations of our analytical framework and evaluating ongoing difficulties in the creation of more international epistemic communities.

地理学学术国际化社会网络分析学术会议