选民如何应对直接民主中的复杂选择?来自瑞士的证据

How Do Voters React to Complex Choices in a Direct Democracy? Evidence from Switzerland

Kyklos · 2016
被引 35
人大 A-ABS 2

中文导读

研究了瑞士1978至2010年间153次联邦公投,发现提案复杂度与赞成票比例呈倒U型关系,并通过微观数据揭示两个相反的作用渠道。

Abstract

Summary Direct democracy may impose significant information demands on voters, especially when individual propositions are highly complex. Yet, it remains theoretically ambiguous how proposition complexity affects referendum outcomes. To explore this question, I use a novel dataset on 153 Swiss federal referendums that took place between 1978 and 2010. The dataset includes hand‐collected data on the number of subjects per proposition based on official pre‐referendum information booklets as a measure of complexity. My estimation results suggest that the relationship between proposition complexity and the share of yes‐votes follows an inverse U‐shape. Using micro‐data from representative post‐referendum surveys, I provide evidence for two opposing channels. More complex propositions are supported by a more diverse group of voters. On the other hand, voters find it more difficult to estimate the personal consequences of complex propositions and are therefore more likely to reject them.

直接民主提案复杂性投票行为瑞士