种族观念的变迁:对量刑研究中异常发现的解释

Changing Conceptions of Race: Towards an Account of Anomalous Findings of Sentencing Research

American Sociological Review · 1984
被引 333
FT 50ABS 4★

中文导读

批判了静态简单的种族观念,通过分析现代反毒品运动中种族和毒品观念的变化对量刑结果的影响,解释了看似矛盾的发现,揭示了量刑中的差异宽容和严厉模式。

Abstract

Theories based on static and simplistic conceptions of the social significance of race fail to account for anomalous research findings and confuse our understanding of race-related outcomes. To substantiate this argument, an analysis is presented of the effects of changing conceptions of race and drugs on sentencing outcomes during a modern anti-drug crusade. This crusade involved a compromise between conservative and liberal impulses in which were identified as villains, while middle-class youth and nonwhites (but the latter only insofar as they were rarely big dealers in a racially stratified drug trade) were reconceived as victims. The results of our contextualized analysis allow us to make sense of otherwise anomalous findings and suggest that while there may be a trend toward equality in American criminal sentencing, there are also patterns of differential leniency and severity that can only be revealed when changing conceptions of race and crime are taken into account.

犯罪学社会学社会心理学种族研究刑事司法