委托竞价与会计准则的分配效应

Delegated Bidding and the Allocative Effect of Accounting Rules

Management Science · 2016
被引 16
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

研究了三种会计准则(购买价格法、退出价值法、使用价值法)在拍卖中对竞价者行为、资产价格和分配效率的影响,发现不同规则会改变买卖双方盈余并影响资产最优配置概率。

Abstract

This paper studies the efficiency and distributive effects of three prominent accounting methods in auction settings when bidders’ incentives are linked to accounting income. The purchase price method (PP) requires the acquirer to book the acquisition at historical cost, thereby underestimating the asset value by the amount of the acquirer’s surplus in the transaction. The exit value method (EV) is downward biased and forces the acquirer to book an accounting loss on the date of acquisition. EV connects otherwise independent valuations inducing a reporting-based winner’s curse and can even lead to fire-sale-like values. Relative to PP, EV implies lower asset prices, a decrease (increase) in the surplus of the seller (acquirer), and an increase in the probability that the asset attains its best use when the market is sufficiently competitive. Finally, I examine an alternative method in which the asset is valued at its perceived value-in-use (VU). Under this method, the acquirer bids more aggressively to increase perceived value-in-use, leading to a shift of surplus from the acquirer to the seller. Yet VU is unbiased and always maximizes the probability that the asset attains its best use. This paper was accepted by Gérard Cachon, accounting.

拍卖会计会计方法资产估值资源配置效率