管理者声誉与内部报告

Managerial Reputation and Internal Reporting

Accounting Review · 1994
被引 26
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

证明管理者对声誉的担忧会扭曲其向上级报告投资项目信息,从而影响公司的资本预算决策,导致投资不足或过度投资。

Abstract

SYNOPSIS AND INTRODUCTION: This paper demonstrates how a manager's concern for reputation can distort reports made to superiors about an investment project and hence, can affect a firm's capital budgeting decisions. In the first setting examined, a manager is assumed to know more than her superior about both her personal abilities and the prospects of a project under consideration. A manager's ability has two dimensions-ability to forecast a project's returns and productivity. A more talented manager has both better forecasting abilities and higher productivity than a less talented manager. It is shown that while a more talented manager always reports her assessment of a firm's project truthfully, a less talented manager's report depends on the magnitude of the difference in productivities between the more and less talented managers. When this productivity gap is large, the less talented manager conceals her lack of talent by claiming that the project's returns are low so as to discourage investment by the firm. Shifting blame to factors beyondhercontrol protects the manager's reputation. Such managerial misreporting results in underinvestment by the firm. In contrast, where the productivity gap between a less talented manager and a more talented manager is small, a less talented manager guards her reputation by sometimes reporting favorable prospects and sometimes unfavorable prospects. This leads the firm either to over- or underinvest its resources, respectively. Thus, managerial misreporting occurs in equilibrium because a less talented manager tries to masquerade as a more talented manager, resulting in investment distortions. Whether a manager's concern for reputation exacerbates or mitigates the incentive problem depends on the manager's type. While the labor market forces align the incentives of a more talented managerwith those of the firm, they also serve to misalign incentives for a less talented manager. In the second setting, this paper examines managerial investment distortion in the choice between short term and long term projects. Consider a scenario in which the

管理者声誉内部报告资本预算投资扭曲