承诺与谎言:观察者能否识别书面信息中的欺骗

Promises and lies: can observers detect deception in written messages

Experimental Economics · 2016
被引 24
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

通过三人信任博弈实验,研究观察者能否预测手写信息的可信度,发现观察者能区分承诺与空话,但无法进一步识别承诺的真假。

Abstract

We design a laboratory experiment to examine predictions of trustworthiness in a novel three-person trust game. We investigate whether and why observers of the game can predict the trustworthiness of hand-written communications. Observers report their perception of the trustworthiness of messages, and make predictions about the senders' behavior. Using observers' decisions, we are able to classify messages as "promises" or "empty talk." Drawing from substantial previous research, we hypothesize that certain factors influence whether a sender is likely to honor a message and/or whether an observer perceives the message as likely to behonored: the mention of money; the use of encompassing words; and message length. We find that observers have more trust in longer messages and "promises"; promises that mention money are significantly more likely to be broken; and observers trust equally in promises that do and do not mention money. Overall, observers perform slightly better than chance at predicting whether a message will be honored. We attribute this result to observers' ability to distinguish promises from empty talk, and to trust promises more than empty talk. However, within each of these two categories, observers are unable to discern between messages that senders will honor from those that they will not.

欺骗检测书面信息承诺信任博弈