解析英国气候政策共识的瓦解:观念、话语与制度的力量

Unravelling the United Kingdom’s climate policy consensus: The power of ideas, discourse and institutions

Global Environmental Change · 2016
被引 125
ABS 3

中文导读

本文运用话语制度主义分析英国2010-2015年联合政府时期气候政策共识如何被关于政府责任和经济紧缩的观念瓦解,对研究政策变迁和气候治理的学者有参考价值。

Abstract

As climate change policies and governance initiatives struggle to produce the transformational social changes required, the search for stand out case studies continues. Many have pointed to the period between 2005 and 2008 in the United Kingdom as a promising example of national level innovation. With strong cross-party consensus and a first-of-its-kind legislation the UK established itself as a climate policy leader. However, early warning signs suggest that this institutionalised position is far from secure. Through a novel application of discursive institutionalism this article presents a detailed analysis of the role of ideas in unravelling this ambition under the Conservative-Liberal coalition administration (2010–2015). Discursive interactions among policymakers and other political actors were dominated by ideas about governmental responsibility and economic austerity, establishing an atmosphere of climate policy scepticism and restraint. By situating this conspicuous and influential process of bricolage within its institutional context the importance of how policymakers think and communicate about climate change is made apparent. The power of ideas to influence policy is further demonstrated through their cognitive and normative persuasiveness, by imposing over and excluding alternatives and in their institutional positioning. It can be concluded that despite innovative legislation, institution building and strategic coordination of different types of governance actors the ideational foundations of ambitious climate change politics in the UK have been undermined.

政治学公共管理气候政策制度主义话语分析