组织与工作场所研究中访谈参与者人数的报告与论证

Reporting and Justifying the Number of Interview Participants in Organization and Workplace Research

BRITISH JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT · 2016
被引 575 · 同刊同年前 2%
人大 A-ABS 4

中文导读

分析了2003年和2013年十本顶级和二级学术期刊中的798篇文章,发现248项研究使用了定性访谈,参与者人数中位数为32.5,但超过半数研究未说明理由,建议组织与工作场所研究的参与者人数规范为15-60人。

Abstract

In this paper we examine established practice regarding the reporting, justification and number of interview participants chosen within organization and workplace studies. For such qualitative research there is a paucity of discussion across the social sciences, the topic receiving far less attention than its centrality warrants. We analysed 798 articles published in 2003 and 2013 in ten top and second tier academic journals, identifying 248 studies using at least one type of qualitative interview. Participant numbers were contingent on characteristics of the population from which they were chosen and approach to analysis, but not the journal, its tier, editorial base or publication year, the interview type or its duration. Despite lack of transparency in reporting (23.4% of studies did not state participant numbers) we reveal a median of 32.5 participants, numbers ranging from one to 330, and no justification for participant numbers in over half of studies. We discuss implications and, recognizing that different philosophical commitments are likely to imply differing norms, offer recommendations regarding reporting, justification and number of participants. Acknowledging exceptions, dependent upon study purpose and data saliency, these include an organization and workplace research norm of 15−60 participants, alongside credible numbers for planning interview research.

组织研究工作场所研究定性研究方法访谈研究