不要简化,要复杂化:从分离式理论到联结式理论——组织与管理研究中的理论构建

Don't Simplify, Complexify: From Disjunctive to Conjunctive Theorizing in Organization and Management Studies

JOURNAL OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES · 2016
被引 356 · 同刊同年前 10%
人大 AFT50ABS 4

中文导读

主张理论构建应追求复杂化而非简化,提出一种联结式理论框架,包含开放本体论、表演性认识论和诗意实践论,以更好地把握组织复杂性。

Abstract

ABSTRACT In this paper I argue that, rather than theory development aim at simplifying complex organizational phenomena, it should aim at complexifying theories – theoretical complexity is needed to account for organizational complexity. Defining the latter as the capacity for ‘nontrivial’ action, I explore a complex ‘system of picturing’ organizations as objects of study that provides an alternative to the hitherto dominant disjunctive style of thinking. A complex ‘system of picturing’ consists of an open‐world ontology, a performative epistemology, and a poetic praxeology. Complex theorizing is conjunctive: it seeks to make connections between diverse elements of human experience through making those analytical distinctions that will enable the joining up of concepts normally used in a compartmentalized manner. Insofar as conjunctive theorizing is driven by the need to preserve the ‘living‐forward – understanding backward’ dialectic, it is better suited to grasping the logic of practice and, thus, to doing justice to organizational complexity. We come close to grasping complexity when we restore the past to its own present and make distinctions that overcome dualisms, preserving as much as possible relationality, temporality, situatedness and, interpretive open‐endedness. I illustrate the argument with several examples from organizational and management research.

组织理论管理研究认识论方法论