惯性、抱负与设计竞赛中对绩效差距的反应

Inertia, aspirations, and response to attainment discrepancy in design contests

R and D Management · 2016
被引 7
ABS 3

中文导读

研究了两种惯性(基于绩效和非基于绩效)如何调节团队在机器人竞赛中根据历史和社会抱负差距进行设计变更的反应,发现绩效惯性对社会抱负差距下的设计变更起负向调节作用。

Abstract

The process of evaluating performance relative to aspirations is widely used by many studies of organizational and technological change. The standard performance feedback model argues that decision makers act in function of attainment discrepancy between performance and aspirations. The theory also states that response to attainment discrepancy is influenced by inertia. Organizational research suggests that there are two types of inertia that we identify in this paper as performance‐based inertia, and nonperformance‐based inertia. We examine the influence of these two types of inertia on the two types of attainment discrepancy as identified by standard performance feedback theory: attainment discrepancy that is based on historical aspirations and attainment discrepancy based on social aspirations. We examine mechanisms that account for the influence of both types of inertia, and derive hypotheses that predict their moderating effect on attainment discrepancy. We test these hypotheses using data on 112 teams that participated in ‘Robot Wars’, a tournament organized as a contest between teams that field machines specifically designed for the event. Our dependent variable is the magnitude of design change prior to participating in each tournament. Our results show, as predicted, that: performance‐based inertia negatively moderates design change in response to attainment discrepancy that is based on social aspirations and; nonperformance‐based inertia negatively moderates design change in response to attainment discrepancy that is based on social aspirations. However, contrary to our predictions, our results show no relationship between nonperformance‐based inertia and design change in response to attainment discrepancy based on historical aspirations. We find a positive and significant result for the relationship between performance‐based inertia and design change in response to attainment discrepancy based on historical aspirations. Our study contributes to research on the relationship between performance feedback and technological decision making in contexts where inertia can alter assessment of new product introduction risks.

组织变革绩效反馈技术决策设计竞赛