拼凑的利维坦:官僚治理的孤岛如何在制度多元的发展中国家蓬勃发展

Patchwork Leviathan: How Pockets of Bureaucratic Governance Flourish within Institutionally Diverse Developing States

American Sociological Review · 2017
被引 161
FT 50ABS 4★

中文导读

研究了发展中国家看似薄弱的国家中为何存在高效运作的官僚孤岛,这些孤岛的组织特征既不同于低效同行,也不同于西方高效组织,并提出了“间隙官僚制”概念来解释其运作机制。

Abstract

Within seemingly weak states, exceptionally effective subunits lie hidden. These high-performing niches exhibit organizational characteristics distinct from poor-performing peer organizations, but also distinct from high-functioning organizations in Western countries. This article develops the concept of interstitial bureaucracy to explain how and why unusually high-performing state organizations in developing countries invert canonical features of Weberian bureaucracy. Interstices are distinct-yet-embedded subsystems characterized by practices inconsistent with those of the dominant institution. This interstitial position poses particular challenges and requires unique solutions. Interstices cluster together scarce proto-bureaucratic resources to cultivate durable distinction from the status quo, while managing disruptions arising from interdependencies with the wider neopatrimonial field. I propose a framework for how bureaucratic interstices respond to those challenges, generalizing from organizational comparisons within the Ghanaian state and abbreviated historical comparison cases from the nineteenth-century United States, early-twentieth-century China, mid-twentieth-century Kenya, and early-twenty-first-century Nigeria.

官僚制国家能力发展中国家的治理组织理论