同舟不同济:地位不一致如何影响商学院的科研绩效

Not in the Same Boat: How Status Inconsistency Affects Research Performance in Business Schools

ACADEMY OF MANAGEMENT JOURNAL · 2017
被引 38
人大 A+FT50UTD24ABS 4*

中文导读

研究了多单元组织中地位不一致(即同一组织在不同社会系统中地位评价不同)对绩效的影响,发现地位不一致会削弱地位对绩效的正面作用,对高地位组织尤其不利,而对低地位组织可能有益。

Abstract

This study examines the consequences of status inconsistency for the performance of multi-unit organizations. Status inconsistency refers to the extent to which social actors occupy status positions accorded different amounts of social esteem and prestige in different social systems. Status inconsistency affects the performance of multi-unit organizations by weakening the well-established positive effects of status on performance because it creates status ambiguity that makes external evaluations of the organization and its individual units more difficult. Distinguishing between high-status and low-status multi-unit organizations, we argue further that status inconsistency is particularly problematic for high-status multi-unit organizations, whereas low-status multi-unit organizations may actually benefit from status inconsistency. We test our arguments using a longitudinal sample comprised of 109 international business schools and their finance, accounting, marketing, management, and operations departments from 2002 to 2013. Our study concludes with a discussion of the contributions our research makes to status theory and research, and the managerial relevance of our findings.

组织行为社会地位商学院管理科研绩效