门格尔的亚里士多德主义

Menger’s Aristotelianism

Cambridge Journal of Economics · 2017
被引 17
人大 A-ABS 3

中文导读

探讨门格尔如何以亚里士多德实在论(而非唯名论)指导经济学研究,主张经济理论应通过理性把握现象形式来抽象,而非从先验公理演绎,对当代经济学方法论仍有启示。

Abstract

How to do economics was one of Menger’s primary interests, his point of view being distinctly Aristotelian, differing in this aspect greatly from his immediate successors, such as Wieser and Böhm-Bawerk, and also from later Austrian economists. Menger’s Aristotelian realism (or classical realism) ran against the nominalist trend of his own and subsequent time, but it may have a more sympathetic hearing now, with remarkable parallels between Aristotelian essentialism and the thesis of theory-laden facts, associated with Rorty, Feyerabend and others. The most important aspect of his Aristotelian realism was his belief that economic theory had to be abstracted from the phenomena by a rational grasp of economic phenomenal forms, Menger explicitly stating that he was not dealing with deductions from a priori axioms. Instead, he was eager to promote what he called exact science. The pursuit of exact science is simply a certain way of treating any subject matter whatever it may be, a certain direction of cognitive endeavour. An exact law provides a theoretical understanding of only one aspect of actual phenomena and neither can be nor need be verified by full empirical actuality. One can still find significance in our time in Menger’s ideas on how to do economics.

门格尔亚里士多德主义经济学方法论精确科学