当你的同类不能住在这里:通用语言和刑事制裁如何塑造社会分类

When Your Kind Cannot Live Here: How Generic Language and Criminal Sanctions Shape Social Categorization

Psychological Science · 2017
被引 13
FT 50ABS 4★

中文导读

研究通过实验发现,用通用语言描述社会群体会降低儿童和成人对个体进行分类时的证据标准,即使分类结果会导致刑事惩罚(如监禁和驱逐出境)。

Abstract

Using generic language to describe groups (applying characteristics to entire categories) is ubiquitous and affects how children and adults categorize other people. Five-year-olds, 8-year-olds, and adults ( N = 190) learned about a novel social group that separated into two factions (citizens and noncitizens). Noncitizens were described in either generic or specific language. Later, the children and adults categorized individuals in two contexts: criminal (individuals labeled as noncitizens faced jail and deportation) and noncriminal (labeling had no consequences). Language genericity influenced decision making. Participants in the specific-language condition, but not those in the generic-language condition, reduced the rate at which they identified potential noncitizens when their judgments resulted in criminal penalties compared with when their judgments had no consequences. In addition, learning about noncitizens in specific language (vs. generic language) increased the amount of matching evidence participants needed to identify potential noncitizens (preponderance standard) and decreased participants' certainty in their judgments. Thus, generic language encourages children and adults to categorize individuals using a lower evidentiary standard regardless of negative consequences for presumed social-group membership.

社会心理学认知心理学发展心理学语言学法律心理学