税务官员在评估公民客户时是否使用双重标准?一项针对荷兰一线税务官员的政策捕捉研究

Do tax officials use double standards in evaluating citizen‐clients? A policy‐capturing study among Dutch frontline tax officials

Public Administration · 2017
被引 44
ABS 4

中文导读

研究荷兰一线税务官员是否对公民客户使用双重标准,发现教育水平可能影响官员对其他信号的解读,为未来研究提供理论和方法指导。

Abstract

In line with psychological and economic discrimination theories, street‐level bureaucracy studies show a direct effect of citizen characteristics on officials' judgements, or show how street‐level bureaucrats employ stereotypical reasoning in making decisions. Relying on sociological double standards theory, this study hypothesizes that citizen‐clients' status characteristics influence officials' evaluations not only directly, but also indirectly and more pervasively by influencing the interpretation of other signals. By means of a policy‐capturing study among Dutch frontline tax officials, this study takes a first step in testing double standards propositions in the context of official–citizen encounters. The findings support only some hypotheses, but indicate that citizen‐clients' level of education could serve as a moderating context affecting the interpretation of cues. The article provides important theoretical and methodological guidelines for future research on stereotyping at the front line.

公共管理税收征管官僚行为歧视理论