非洲暴力与社会动荡研究:三个冲突事件数据集的比较分析

The study of violence and social unrest in Africa: A comparative analysis of three conflict event datasets

African Affairs · 2018
被引 28
ABS 3

中文导读

比较三个冲突事件数据集(SCAD、ACLED和基于尼日利亚本地来源的数据集)在记录非洲冲突事件上的差异,发现数据集在事件数量、次国家分布上存在重要差异,提醒使用者注意数据源选择的影响。

Abstract

African conflicts are highly represented in cross-national conflict event datasets, and their causes are increasingly investigated in quantitative analyses. Many of these datasets make use of international media reports to compile information on different forms of conflict events, ranging from violent armed conflict to forms of social unrest such as protests and riots. African studies scholars more commonly rely on local news sources to study these phenomena. In this research note, we investigate the effect of using different types of news sources to analyze conflict patterns in Africa by comparing the coverage of conflict events in Nigeria by three datasets: The Social Conflict in Africa Database (SCAD), the Armed Conflict Location and Event Dataset (ACLED) and a dataset developed by the authors, based on Nigerian sources and focusing on the period April 2014–March 2015. We investigate the overlap between the datasets and whether this is affected by event characteristics, including violent and non-violent events. The comparison shows empirically the important differences that can exist, in terms of both the absolute number and the sub-national distribution of reported conflict events. Such variations between datasets in terms of event, but also time and geographical coverage require careful reflection by users.

非洲研究冲突分析数据比较政治学