监控技术的有效性:情报官员在说什么

The effectiveness of surveillance technology: What intelligence officials are saying

Information Society · 2018
被引 44
ABS 3

中文导读

分析了2006至2016年间美英情报官员的公开声明,找出他们评价监控技术有效性的七项标准,并发现成本虽少被提及,却是正式评估背后的关键因素。

Abstract

In recent years, Western governments have come under sharp criticism for their use of surveillance technology. They have been accused of sweeping up massive amounts of information without evidence of the technologies being effective in improving security. The view of critics is clear, but what do intelligence officials themselves say? This paper analyzes statements of intelligence officials in the U.S. and U.K. from 2006 to 2016, examines what criteria officials use in their discourse on effectiveness, and investigates how considerations of cost and proportionality factor into the equation. It identifies seven measures of effectiveness in the statements of intelligence officials, and finds that cost, though rarely discussed, is the driver behind formalized evaluations of surveillance programs.

情报分析公共政策法律政治学社会学